Advice Needed for school project
-
- WRA2 Member
- Posts: 23
- Joined: Sat Jul 27, 2013 10:33 am
Advice Needed for school project
My Son is entering a water rocket challage at his school and as i have some experience in water rockets he was hoping i would help him win
there are a few problems,umm sorry,Rules!
rocket will launch from a flat surface for they are not allowed any fins below the centre line!
rocket will launch at 30 degrees so distance will be measured not height
rocket can only have 300ml of water
rocket will be pressurised to an unknown pressure, probably low
rocket has to be ready by Thursday morning (today is Monday!)
So any tips or recommendation to help us win would be a great help
Kind Regards
Lee
there are a few problems,umm sorry,Rules!
rocket will launch from a flat surface for they are not allowed any fins below the centre line!
rocket will launch at 30 degrees so distance will be measured not height
rocket can only have 300ml of water
rocket will be pressurised to an unknown pressure, probably low
rocket has to be ready by Thursday morning (today is Monday!)
So any tips or recommendation to help us win would be a great help
Kind Regards
Lee
LSD
Yes, I Am a Rocket Scientist.
Yes, I Am a Rocket Scientist.
-
- WRA2 Member
- Posts: 1087
- Joined: Wed Dec 19, 2012 2:47 am
Re: Advice Needed for school project
Sounds more like they want a glider than a rocket.lowerstoford wrote:My Son is entering a water rocket challage at his school and as i have some experience in water rockets he was hoping i would help him win
there are a few problems,umm sorry,Rules!
rocket will launch from a flat surface for they are not allowed any fins below the centre line!
rocket will launch at 30 degrees so distance will be measured not height
rocket can only have 300ml of water
rocket will be pressurised to an unknown pressure, probably low
rocket has to be ready by Thursday morning (today is Monday!)
So any tips or recommendation to help us win would be a great help
Kind Regards
Lee
can you arrange the fins more like an airplane?
Bugwubber
Team S.P.E.W.
Team S.P.E.W.
-
- WRA2 Member
- Posts: 1087
- Joined: Wed Dec 19, 2012 2:47 am
Re: Advice Needed for school project
You can try just a tennis ball taped to the front, or
perhaps sharp delta wings with heavy dihedral and a verticle stabilizer. Almost like a lifting body. Perhaps tape reinforced foam core posterboard.
perhaps sharp delta wings with heavy dihedral and a verticle stabilizer. Almost like a lifting body. Perhaps tape reinforced foam core posterboard.
Bugwubber
Team S.P.E.W.
Team S.P.E.W.
-
- WRA2 Member
- Posts: 23
- Joined: Sat Jul 27, 2013 10:33 am
Re: Advice Needed for school project
We have a weighted nose cone ready.
i was thinking if delta wing, i have been trying to figure out best size?
i am also considering tube fins as all my other rockets use them
1 large and angled on each side on small straight on the top ?
Lee
i was thinking if delta wing, i have been trying to figure out best size?
i am also considering tube fins as all my other rockets use them
1 large and angled on each side on small straight on the top ?
Lee
LSD
Yes, I Am a Rocket Scientist.
Yes, I Am a Rocket Scientist.
-
- WRA2 Member
- Posts: 1087
- Joined: Wed Dec 19, 2012 2:47 am
Re: Advice Needed for school project
As an archer, I tend to prefer minimal fins. I don't think you will get a distance boost having large fins or wings. You'll probably just get a lot of drag right at launch followed by a slow glide that might be hampered further by wind condition.lowerstoford wrote:We have a weighted nose cone ready.
i was thinking if delta wing, i have been trying to figure out best size?
i am also considering tube fins as all my other rockets use them
1 large and angled on each side on small straight on the top ?
Lee
Case in point: [youtube][/youtube]
Bugwubber
Team S.P.E.W.
Team S.P.E.W.
-
- WRA2 Member
- Posts: 23
- Joined: Sat Jul 27, 2013 10:33 am
Re: Advice Needed for school project
We do have a chance of some test launches on Wednesday evening
Wind will be the same as forecast for Friday
So I could make up a few different configurations and test which is best
Wind will be the same as forecast for Friday
So I could make up a few different configurations and test which is best
LSD
Yes, I Am a Rocket Scientist.
Yes, I Am a Rocket Scientist.
-
- WRA2 Member
- Posts: 1087
- Joined: Wed Dec 19, 2012 2:47 am
Re: Advice Needed for school project
lowerstoford wrote:We do have a chance of some test launches on Wednesday evening
Wind will be the same as forecast for Friday
So I could make up a few different configurations and test which is best
Cool what size bottles will y'all be using? Are these going on a full bore or gardena launcher?
Bugwubber
Team S.P.E.W.
Team S.P.E.W.
-
- WRA2 Member
- Posts: 622
- Joined: Fri Nov 22, 2013 10:39 am
Re: Advice Needed for school project
I don't see how a rocket can be stable with the fins half way up the rocket. Do the people running the event know much about rockets? Maybe it's time to talk to someone in charge.
Water Rocket Expert
I'm 20
Maryland
"Anyone who has never made a mistake has never tried anything new." -Albert Einstein
I'm 20
Maryland
"Anyone who has never made a mistake has never tried anything new." -Albert Einstein
-
- WRA2 Member
- Posts: 1087
- Joined: Wed Dec 19, 2012 2:47 am
Re: Advice Needed for school project
You need to visit flight school then cause Chuck Yeager has a few words for you on the matter. I've decided to build what I suggested to lowerstoford so we can see if ole bugwubber is largely full of it. Will launch it tomorrow morning.Water Rocket Expert wrote:I don't see how a rocket can be stable with the fins half way up the rocket. Do the people running the event know much about rockets? Maybe it's time to talk to someone in charge.
Bugwubber
Team S.P.E.W.
Team S.P.E.W.
-
- WRA2 Member
- Posts: 622
- Joined: Fri Nov 22, 2013 10:39 am
Re: Advice Needed for school project
Sounds good. Bring on the report.
Water Rocket Expert
I'm 20
Maryland
"Anyone who has never made a mistake has never tried anything new." -Albert Einstein
I'm 20
Maryland
"Anyone who has never made a mistake has never tried anything new." -Albert Einstein
-
- WRA2 Member
- Posts: 1087
- Joined: Wed Dec 19, 2012 2:47 am
Re: Advice Needed for school project
First, by centerline, assuming you meant with the rocket on its side.
Anyway here's the first flight of me taking own advice
[youtube][/youtube]
Anyway here's the first flight of me taking own advice
[youtube][/youtube]
Bugwubber
Team S.P.E.W.
Team S.P.E.W.
-
- WRA2 Member
- Posts: 23
- Joined: Sat Jul 27, 2013 10:33 am
Re: Advice Needed for school project
Tonight we have read the rules again, only to discover they are only allowed a fin on ONE SIDE!!
I just cant see how this would make any difference at all, so we have decided to have no fins and a heavy nose cone.
We have performed 5 test launches this evening, changing the weight on the first 4 and the 5th was to verify the test results.
We measured the distance the "rocket" tumbled through the air to determine the best nose cone weight
i will upload the rules later so you can all have a laugh at this "rocket challenge"
Videos of the test launches will be added later too.
There are too many unknowns with this, I have no confidence that my son's team will win.
But we are the only ones that have been able to test launch, so you never know.
If it was a real rocket then things would be different.
I just cant see how this would make any difference at all, so we have decided to have no fins and a heavy nose cone.
We have performed 5 test launches this evening, changing the weight on the first 4 and the 5th was to verify the test results.
We measured the distance the "rocket" tumbled through the air to determine the best nose cone weight
i will upload the rules later so you can all have a laugh at this "rocket challenge"
Videos of the test launches will be added later too.
There are too many unknowns with this, I have no confidence that my son's team will win.
But we are the only ones that have been able to test launch, so you never know.
If it was a real rocket then things would be different.
LSD
Yes, I Am a Rocket Scientist.
Yes, I Am a Rocket Scientist.
-
- WRA2 Member
- Posts: 1087
- Joined: Wed Dec 19, 2012 2:47 am
Re: Advice Needed for school project
Hmm, wonder if you could get your hands on a giant foam golf ball or some other way to put dimples. Wonder if you can get away with that "fin" being in the form of a wooden dowel that hangs out the back 2ft. Like a bottle rocket...lowerstoford wrote:Tonight we have read the rules again, only to discover they are only allowed a fin on ONE SIDE!!
I just cant see how this would make any difference at all, so we have decided to have no fins and a heavy nose cone.
We have performed 5 test launches this evening, changing the weight on the first 4 and the 5th was to verify the test results.
We measured the distance the "rocket" tumbled through the air to determine the best nose cone weight
i will upload the rules later so you can all have a laugh at this "rocket challenge"
Videos of the test launches will be added later too.
There are too many unknowns with this, I have no confidence that my son's team will win.
But we are the only ones that have been able to test launch, so you never know.
If it was a real rocket then things would be different.
Well, anyway good luck!
Bugwubber
Team S.P.E.W.
Team S.P.E.W.
-
- WRA2 Member
- Posts: 622
- Joined: Fri Nov 22, 2013 10:39 am
Re: Advice Needed for school project
You can only have one fin? That sounds more like a rudder to me. These rules are goofy.
Water Rocket Expert
I'm 20
Maryland
"Anyone who has never made a mistake has never tried anything new." -Albert Einstein
I'm 20
Maryland
"Anyone who has never made a mistake has never tried anything new." -Albert Einstein
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1089
- Joined: Sat Dec 30, 2006 11:30 pm
Re: Advice Needed for school project
Sounds like the rules are designed to limit all rockets performance. Is the launch site too small and they are confining the rockets to within a specified area by making rules to limit performance.lowerstoford wrote:Tonight we have read the rules again, only to discover they are only allowed a fin on ONE SIDE!!
I just cant see how this would make any difference at all, so we have decided to have no fins and a heavy nose cone.
We have performed 5 test launches this evening, changing the weight on the first 4 and the 5th was to verify the test results.
We measured the distance the "rocket" tumbled through the air to determine the best nose cone weight
i will upload the rules later so you can all have a laugh at this "rocket challenge"
Videos of the test launches will be added later too.
There are too many unknowns with this, I have no confidence that my son's team will win.
But we are the only ones that have been able to test launch, so you never know.
If it was a real rocket then things would be different.
Lisa Walker,
Forum Administrator.
The Water Rocket Achievement World Record Association
Forum Administrator.
The Water Rocket Achievement World Record Association